Orgain vs Optimum Nutrition

Compare Orgain and Optimum Nutrition by Index /100, $/25g protein, and nutrition.

Swipe across to compare

01
Orgain 21g Grass-Fed Whey Protein Powder, 5g BCAAs, Vanilla Bean, 1.82lb | Dairy protein, 5g BCAAs, 3g prebiotic fiber, no sugar added, no added hormones, gluten free, kosher, for shakes & smoothies
Orgain

21g Grass-Fed Whey Protein Powder, 5g BCAAs, Vanilla Bean

View product
02
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard Whey Vanilla Ice Cream - 5 lbs .
Optimum Nutrition

Gold Standard Whey Vanilla Ice Cream

View product
Index score
—UnscoredIndex / 100
—UnscoredIndex / 100
Cost / 25g protein
$1.88
$1.07
Protein / serving
21g
24g
Formulation / 100
—
—
Sugar / 25g protein
1.2g
1.0g
Flavor
vanilla
vanilla

Build your own comparison

Frequently asked questions

Is Orgain better than Optimum Nutrition?

It depends on the SKU. Compare live Index /100 (formulation checks, sugar, value) and $/25g on this page — brand reputation alone is not a score.

How does WheyIndex score these brands?

Index /100 weights formulation (60%), sugar per 25g protein (30%), and same-market value (10%). Affiliate relationships never change scores. See /how-the-index-works.